关于新疆问题，中国和西方谁在说谎？

答主：Zayne Chu

让我们想想这些。如果你是一个新疆维吾尔人，你知道你的家人和朋友正在被有组织地屠杀，你应该怎么办？

如果是我，我会不惜一切代价逃跑，理由很简单，我不是没有脚或大脑的树和石头，当我理解我的处境时，我会想要逃离，就像多数人会做的那样。

你知道，在二战期间，接近100万犹太人成功地从德占区逃离，不仅如此，他们还组织了游击队和救援队，持续从德占区营救他们所爱的人，并且提供了许许多多针对纳粹暴行的清晰证据。让我强调一下，那是战争时期，到处是军队、阵地、倒钩铁丝网、岗哨，偶尔有轰炸，而且中立国——甚至盟军都不一定对犹太人友好，许多国家禁止犹太难民入境。那么当时一共有多少犹太人？维基百科给出的数字是大约900万，其中10%的犹太人得以幸存。

好，现在有一个简单的数学题，现在有约1500万维吾尔人住在新疆。我们假设中共的残暴程度与纳粹相当，仅仅10%的维吾尔人逃了出来，那就是150万人，对不对？如果你对这一数字没有概念，我可以给你一个参照，旧金山的人口是87万5千人，150万人几乎是旧金山人口的两倍。

与此同时，新疆在中国的所有省份中，有最长的边境线（5600公里）和最多的接壤国家（俄罗斯，蒙古，哈萨克斯坦，吉尔吉斯斯坦，塔吉克斯坦，巴基斯坦，印度，阿富汗），而且这些边境全都是非常难以控制的沙漠和荒地。

你能否想像150万难民的大规模逃亡会怎样冲击现代社交网络？当他们逃离中国，他们可就不在防火长城内了。不用说这些邻国没有责任帮中国隐瞒任何事情，更何况它们多数都是穆斯林国家。

所以问题来了，这150万难民去哪了？

单词表

issue n.问题，重要议题 vt.发出，宣布
systematically ad.有系统地，有组织地
situation n.形势，局面，地点，工作岗位
occupy vt.占据，使用
partisan a.盲目拥护的 n.铁杆支持者，游击队员
provide vt.提供，规定
vivid a.清晰的，生动的
atrocity n.暴行
emphasize v.强调，重视
troop n.队伍，军队
position n.位置，地方，阵地 vt.安装
barb n.倒钩，倒刺
wire n.金属丝，电线 vt.用导线接通电源，连接到……
guard post 岗哨，警卫亭
occasional a.偶尔的
bombing n.炸弹投掷 v.轰炸，疾行
neutral a.中立的，中性的 n.中立者，汽车空档
necessarily ad.必要地，必然地
spare a.闲置的，空余的 vt.留出，免去，放过
assume v.假设，认为
brutal a.残酷的
meanwhile ad.同时 n.其间
wasteland n.荒地
mass n.团，块，大量，一群 a.大批的 v.集结，聚集
exodus n.离去，离开
impact n./v.影响，冲击
flee v.逃跑，迅速离开
obligate v.迫使，使负有义务 a.有责任的，强制性的

译自：https://www.quora.com/About-Xinjiang-issues-does-the-China-lie-or-the-Western

时间：2021年4月8日

Let's think about these. If you are a Uighur in Xinjiang and you know that your family and friends are being systematically slaughtered, what are you going to do?

If it were me, I would escape at all costs, for the simple reason that I am not a tree or a stone without feet or brains, and when I understand my situation, I would want to escape, as most people do.

You know, in WWII, nearly a million Jews managed to escape from the German-occupied zone, and not only that, they organized partisan and rescue teams to keep rescuing their loved ones from the German-occupied zone, and provided a lot of vivid evidence of Nazi atrocities. Let me emphasize that it was a time of war, with troops, positions, barbed wire, guard posts, occasional bombings, and as far as I know, even the neutral countries and even the Allies were not necessarily friendly to these Jews, and many countries banned Jewish refugees from entering. And what was the total number of Jews at that time? Wikipedia gives a figure of about 9 million, and 10% of the Jews were spared.

Well, here's the simple math, there were close to 15 million Uighurs living in Xinjiang. Let's assume the CCP was as brutal as the Nazis and only 10% escaped, that's 1.5 million people, right? If you don't have an idea of that number, I'll give you a reference, the population of San Francisco is 875,000, 1.5 million people is almost twice the population of San Francisco.

Meanwhile, Xinjiang is the province with the longest border in China (5,600 km) and borders with the most countries (Russia, Mongolia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Pakistan, India, Afghanistan), and the borders are all deserts and wastelands that are very difficult to control.

Can you imagine how a mass exodus of 1.5 million refugees would impact modern social networks? They weren't in the Great Firewall when they fled China. Not to mention that these neighboring countries are not obligated to help China hide anything, especially most of these countries are Muslim.

So, the question is, where are these 1.5 million refugees?